Fonteum Care Compare · Pennsylvania · Erie
Nursing homes in Erie, Pennsylvania: 14 Medicare-certified facilities.
CMS overall star rating, staffing rating, health inspection rating, and ownership type for every Medicare-certified nursing home in Erie — every column traced to the CMS Care Compare NH Provider Information dataset (4pq5-n9py).
Average CMS overall rating in Erie: 3.9 / 5
How Erie compares
Erie vs the Pennsylvania state average
Overall ★ — this city
3.9
State avg 3.0 / 5
+0.9 vs state
Staffing ★ — this city
3.5
State avg 3.1 / 5
+0.4 vs state
Facilities — this city
14
657 statewide
State averages are CMS-published per-state means from the same snapshot; the city figure is the mean across the 14 rated facilities above.
Where Erie sits
All 14 Medicare-certified nursing homes in Erie sit in Erie County, Pennsylvania. County is the geographic unit CMS uses for staffing-desert and access analysis.
All Medicare-certified nursing homes in Erie, Pennsylvania
Sarah Reed Senior Living
227 West 22nd Street · CCN 395206 · Non profit - Corporation
106 certified beds · 98.5 avg daily residents · 4.44 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 5 / 5 · Last standard survey December 4, 2025
5
Overall
4
Staffing
4 / 5
Health Insp.
Ball Pavilion, The
5416 East Lake Road · CCN 395401 · Non profit - Church related
85 certified beds · 66.5 avg daily residents · 4.30 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 2 / 5 · Last standard survey March 21, 2025
5
Overall
5
Staffing
4 / 5
Health Insp.
Lecom At Elmwood Gardens, Llc
2628 Elmwood Avenue · CCN 395474 · Non profit - Corporation
51 certified beds · 47.5 avg daily residents · 4.15 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 5 / 5 · Last standard survey February 13, 2026
5
Overall
4
Staffing
5 / 5
Health Insp.
Forestview
2301 Edinboro Road · CCN 395907 · Non profit - Corporation
80 certified beds · 72.8 avg daily residents · 3.86 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 4 / 5 · Last standard survey August 28, 2025
5
Overall
4
Staffing
5 / 5
Health Insp.
Manchester Commons Of Presbyterian Seniorcare
6351 West Lake Road · CCN 395996 · Non profit - Corporation
78 certified beds · 72.3 avg daily residents · 5.00 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 4 / 5 · Last standard survey July 2, 2025
5
Overall
5
Staffing
4 / 5
Health Insp.
Millcreek Manor
5535 Peach Street · CCN 396072 · Non profit - Corporation
144 certified beds · 138.2 avg daily residents · 4.41 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 4 / 5 · Last standard survey January 23, 2026
5
Overall
5
Staffing
4 / 5
Health Insp.
Lecom At Asbury Ridge Dba Saint Mary'S Asbury Ridg
4855 West Ridge Road · CCN 396081 · Non profit - Corporation
80 certified beds · 75.2 avg daily residents · 4.18 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 4 / 5 · Last standard survey September 12, 2025
5
Overall
4
Staffing
5 / 5
Health Insp.
Walnut Creek Nursing And Rehab
4850 Zuck Road · CCN 395200 · For profit - Limited Liability company
115 certified beds · 104 avg daily residents · 3.68 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 3 / 5 · Last standard survey May 22, 2025
4
Overall
4
Staffing
4 / 5
Health Insp.
Lecom At Village Square, Llc
149 West 22nd Street · CCN 395672 · Non profit - Corporation
110 certified beds · 100.3 avg daily residents · 3.50 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 4 / 5 · Last standard survey December 18, 2025
4
Overall
3
Staffing
4 / 5
Health Insp.
Twinbrook Healthcare And Rehabilitation Center
3805 Field Street · CCN 395041 · For profit - Limited Liability company
118 certified beds · QM 2 / 5 · Last standard survey April 25, 2025
3
Overall
—
Staffing
3 / 5
Health Insp.
Nightingale Nursing And Rehab Center
607 East 26th Street · CCN 395042 · For profit - Limited Liability company
139 certified beds · 114 avg daily residents · 3.76 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 4 / 5 · Last standard survey February 20, 2026
3
Overall
2
Staffing
3 / 5
Health Insp.
Lecom At Presque Isle, Inc
4114 Schaper Avenue · CCN 395404 · Non profit - Corporation
135 certified beds · 106.3 avg daily residents · 3.96 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 4 / 5 · Last standard survey January 8, 2026
3
Overall
3
Staffing
3 / 5
Health Insp.
Pennsylvania Soldiers And Sailors Home
560 East Third St · CCN 39A434 · Government - State
107 certified beds · 101 avg daily residents · QM 2 / 5 · Last standard survey March 7, 2025
2
Overall
1
Staffing
3 / 5
Health Insp.
Greenfield Healthcare And Rehabilitation Center
1521 West 54th Street · CCN 395262 · For profit - Limited Liability company
133 certified beds · 67 avg daily residents · 3.25 total nurse hrs/resident-day · QM 1 / 5 · Last standard survey January 27, 2026
1
Overall
2
Staffing
1 / 5
Health Insp.
Reading the data
What these CMS ratings mean
Every star column on this page comes straight from CMS’s Five-Star Quality Rating System. Fonteum re-publishes the federal numbers without re-scoring them — the definitions below are CMS’s, not ours.
- Overall star rating
- A 1-to-5 summary CMS derives from the health-inspection, staffing, and quality-measure ratings. It is a relative ranking, not an absolute score — roughly the top fifth of facilities earn 5 stars and the bottom fifth earn 1.
- Health inspection rating
- Based on the three most recent state standard surveys plus any complaint investigations, weighted toward recency. More and more severe deficiencies lower the rating.
- Staffing rating
- Built from payroll-based (PBJ) nurse staffing hours per resident day, case-mix adjusted, including registered-nurse hours and weekend coverage.
- Quality-measure (QM) rating
- Drawn from a set of MDS- and claims-based clinical measures (e.g. pressure ulcers, falls, hospitalisation, antipsychotic use) across short- and long-stay residents.
- Special Focus Facility (SFF)
- A separate CMS program flagging facilities with a persistent pattern of serious health-inspection problems. “SFF” marks an active designation; “SFF Candidate” marks a facility on the candidate list.
Full methodology: how Fonteum sources and signs CMS nursing-home data.
Other Pennsylvania cities with nursing homes
Compare Erie with nearby markets — facility counts from the same CMS snapshot.
Fonteum research on nursing-home quality
Star ratings vs actual resident harm
Where CMS overall stars diverge from documented harm-level deficiencies.
Nursing-home staffing deserts by county
Counties where reported nurse hours per resident day fall furthest behind.
Nursing-home ownership networks
How chain ownership concentrates across Medicare-certified facilities.
Facilities banned from new Medicare admissions
Payment-denial enforcement actions and the facilities they hit.